Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Erika Intelligence's avatar

The line about judgment surviving is the one I keep getting stuck on. Judgment usually gets built by doing the drudgery badly for a few years first, so if the bottom rungs are the part that gets automated, I'm not sure where the next generation of people with good judgment is supposed to come from.

Graham L's avatar

Interesting, and certainly disruptive. Where it is going is another question, really. We can't have a Star-Trek economic fantasy with no economy - what do you do with the pension funds? Who puts the effort into constructing the starships, and in return for what? No, at the end of this, we still have to have billionaires and loads of people who rent everything from them instead of actually owning more - which is what real (material) abundance looks like. Don't get me wrong, I understand Pareto distributions and I have nothing against billionaires and I love Elon Musk to bits. And I understand also that "abundance" is present in the world to a literally unprecedented degree, in the sense of healthcare and life expectancy and technology and continually falling rates of extreme poverty.

But we can't dismantle incentives and motivations. And "abundance", to me, will continue to mean not just more peace and lifespan and gadgets, but owning things and funds with which to exercise your freedom in your chosen ways. We seem to move away from that constantly, e.g. if you want a movie, you can't any longer own a DVD and play it whenever YOU choose to - you are subject to the whims and withdrawals and takeovers and ideologies of streaming platforms. That kind of freedom, that has virtually been removed, is a form of abundance. And musical artists, except for a tiny minority, did far better out or people buying their records/tapes/CDs than out of streaming platform royalties. I agree it's a constantly improving world in so many ways and that I'm being picky or spoilt here. But it's a warped kind of abundance at the moment, and not at the lower levels of the economic hierarchies.

53 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?